Skip to content

My Future Mother-in-Law Turned Our Wedding Into a Cruel Joke About My Weight, Then My Fiancé Made Her Regret It

  • by

I don’t remember my own vows. Jordan says I said them. She says they were very good. She says I only cried through half of them.

I just remember Bruce’s face. And my mother in the front row, holding the hand of the empty chair next to her like there was somebody in it.

And the two small figures at the gate. Standing very still.

When the officiant said, “You may kiss the bride,” Bruce kissed me. The whole lawn cheered.

And at the gate, very far away, I saw one of those figures put her hands over her face.


The reception was in the barn.

It was everything I’d wanted. Strings of little lights hanging from the rafters. Long wooden tables. A band playing old Motown songs. My mother dancing with Uncle Pete, laughing so hard her silver butterfly comb fell out of her hair.

I ate.

I ate everything. The chicken. The mashed potatoes. The rolls. Three rolls. With butter. When the caterers brought out the dessert table, there was a pie on it. Apple, with a lattice top and sugar sprinkled on it.

I hadn’t ordered pie. I’d ordered a cake.

I looked at Bruce. He shrugged, grinning. “I asked your mom for the recipe,” he said. “I made it this morning. At four a.m. Before I came here. Don’t tell anybody. It’s a little burned on one side.”

I cut myself a slice. A big one.

It was a little burned on one side. It was the best thing I’d ever tasted.


Around eight o’clock, the sun was starting to go down. Everything outside turned gold. Jordan came and found me at the dessert table.

“Tess,” she said quietly. “She’s here.”

I turned around.

Jacqueline was standing in the big open doorway of the barn.

Nana June was beside her, holding her arm. Jacqueline wasn’t wearing her hat anymore. Her hair was a little messy. Her makeup was smeared. Her sunglasses were pushed up on top of her head, and her eyes were red and swollen.

She looked smaller. That’s the only word I have for it. She looked smaller than I’d ever seen her.

The band was still playing. Most people didn’t notice her. But a few did. Bruce’s uncle. Some cousins. My mother, at her table, went very still.

Bruce was on the dance floor with Jordan’s husband doing something embarrassing to My Girl. He saw his mother. He stopped dancing.

He looked at me across the barn.

I nodded.

I put down my plate. I walked across the barn to the door.


We went outside. The three of us. Me and Jacqueline and Nana June. Around the side of the barn, where it was quieter. Where the crane was still parked beside the lawn, its long yellow arm pointing up into the gold sky.

Nana June lowered herself onto a hay bale. Jacqueline stood in front of me.

For a long time, she didn’t say anything.

“I’ve been sitting in my car,” she said finally. Her voice was rough, like she’d been crying for hours. “All day. At the gate. I couldn’t make myself drive away. And I couldn’t make myself come up here.” She laughed a little. “I watched the whole ceremony from the fence. I heard the vows. The wind was blowing the right way.”

I didn’t say anything.

“My mother told me,” Jacqueline said. She glanced at Nana June. “That she talked to you. That she told you about… when I was little.”

“She did.”

Jacqueline’s jaw tightened. For a second, she looked angry. Then it went away. She just looked tired.

“I’ve never told anyone,” she said. “Not Bruce. Not my husband, when I had one. Nobody.”

“I’m sorry,” I said. “About what happened to you.”

“Don’t,” she said. “Don’t be sorry for me. Not today. I don’t deserve it.” She took a breath. “I came to apologize. Bruce told me that’s what I had to do. And he’s right.”

She looked at me. Straight at me. For the first time in five years, I felt like she was actually looking at me. Not at my arms. Not at my plate. At me.

“I’m sorry,” she said. “For the dress shop. For Christmas. For the pie. For every single thing I’ve said about your body since the day Bruce proposed. I’m sorry for the crane.” Her voice broke. “God. The crane. I can’t believe I did that. I planned it for two months. I called three companies. I picked out the bow.”

She put her hand over her mouth.

“I told myself it was funny,” she said through her fingers. “I told myself everyone would laugh. I told myself you’d laugh. But I knew. I knew exactly what it would feel like. Because I’ve felt it. My whole life. Every time somebody moved the plate away.”

She lowered her hand.

“I did to you exactly what was done to me,” she said. “And I knew I was doing it. And I did it anyway. Because some part of me couldn’t stand it. That you’d get to be happy. At your size. That he’d love you anyway. That you’d eat pie at your own wedding and nobody would weigh you on Sunday morning.” She was crying now. Really crying. “I’ve never gotten to eat the pie, Tessa. Not once. Not in fifty years.”

I stood there in the gold light next to the barn, listening to the band play Ain’t No Mountain High Enough through the wall.

And I didn’t know what to feel.

I wanted to be angry. I was angry. For a year, this woman had made me feel like something was wrong with me. Like I was too much. Like the body that had carried my mother through cancer was something to be embarrassed about.

But I was looking at her now. At her red eyes and her smeared makeup and her hands shaking at her sides.

And I saw a ten-year-old girl in a nightgown, standing on a bathroom scale before church.

“Jacqueline,” I said. “I accept your apology.”

She looked up.

“I don’t forgive you yet,” I said. “I want to be honest with you. I don’t know if I can. Not today. Maybe not for a long time. What you did hurt me. A lot. I started counting too. Every bite. For months. I cried in the dressing room two weeks ago. I almost didn’t eat at my own wedding.”

Her face crumpled.

“But I accept it,” I said. “And I’m going to tell you what Bruce told you. There are rules now. If you ever say one word about my body again, you’re done. Not just with me. With us. With our kids, if we have kids. And if we have a daughter,” I stopped. I had to take a breath. “If we have a daughter, you will never, ever say a single word about her weight. Not one. Not a joke. Not a comment. Not moving a plate. Not ever.”

“Never,” Jacqueline whispered. “I swear. Never.”

Behind her, on the hay bale, Nana June was crying into a handkerchief.

“And,” I said, “I think you should talk to somebody. A therapist. About… about all of it. About the scale. About the counting. Because I don’t think you can stop doing it to other people until somebody helps you stop doing it to yourself.”

Jacqueline looked at me for a long moment.

Then she nodded.

“Okay,” she said. “Okay.”


We went back inside.

Bruce was standing just inside the barn door. He’d been waiting. He looked at his mother. At her face. Then at me.

“Are you okay?” he asked me.

“I’m okay.”

He turned to his mother. For a long moment, they just looked at each other.

“I’m sorry, Bruce,” Jacqueline said. “About the crane. About all of it. I’m so sorry.”

“I know, Mom.”

“You were right to do what you did.”

“I know.”

She almost laughed. “You don’t have to agree so fast.”

“Yeah, I do,” Bruce said. But he was smiling a little.

Then he did something I didn’t expect. He reached out and hugged her. Awkwardly. Stiffly. Like he wasn’t sure if he should.

Jacqueline held on to him like she was drowning.

“You lifted my car,” she said into his shoulder. “You lifted my car, Bruce. With a crane.”

“You’re the one who rented it.”

“I know.”

“For the whole day.”

“I know.”

“Seemed like a waste not to use it.”

Jacqueline started laughing. Crying and laughing at the same time.


My mother was the one who came up with the idea.

It was almost dark. The sky was pink and orange over the pond. We were all standing outside the barn, getting ready for the sparkler send-off. Everybody was holding their little sparklers, waiting for somebody to light them.

My mother was looking at the crane.

“Is that thing still running?” she asked Earl. The crane operator. Who’d stayed all day, it turned out, because Jacqueline had paid for it, and because, he said, “I haven’t had this much fun on a job in thirty years.”

“Runs fine,” Earl said. “Why?”

“Does it have one of those baskets?” my mother asked. “The kind people stand in?”

Earl grinned. “Personnel platform. It’s in the back of the truck. Certified for four people. Nine hundred pounds.”

My mother looked at me. Then at Bruce. Then at Jacqueline.

“Well,” my mother said. “Somebody did say we’d need help lifting the bride.”


Earl hooked the metal basket onto the crane. It was big and yellow, with safety rails and a little gate. He strapped us all into safety harnesses. He checked every buckle twice.

Me in my wedding dress. Bruce in his gray suit. My mother in her blue dress with the silver butterfly comb back in her hair.

At the last second, my mother reached out and grabbed Jacqueline’s hand.

“Come on,” she said.

Jacqueline stared at her. “Me?”

“There’s room for four,” my mother said. “Nine hundred pounds. Earl said.”

Jacqueline looked at the basket. At me. At Bruce.

“I don’t think I should,” she said.

“Jacqueline,” my mother said. “I just spent a year fighting to stay alive. I’ve learned a few things. One of them is, when somebody offers you a view, you take it.”

Jacqueline hesitated for a long moment.

Then she stepped into the basket.

Earl strapped her in. He closed the little gate. He climbed back into his cab.

“Hang on, folks,” he called.

The engine rumbled.

And slowly, gently, the crane lifted us up into the sky.


I’ve never seen anything like it.

We went up and up. Past the roof of the barn. Past the top of the big oak tree. Up over the lawn with its rows of empty chairs and its white arch. Up over the pond. Up until the whole farm was spread out below us like a little toy world.

The sun was just going down behind the hills. The whole sky was on fire. Pink and gold and purple. The pond was a mirror, reflecting all of it. Far below, all of our guests were standing on the lawn, holding their sparklers, looking up at us. Somebody had lit them. A hundred tiny stars sparkling in the dusk.

Everybody was cheering. We could hear them all the way up there.

Bruce put his arm around me.

My mother leaned against the rail and looked out at the sunset. She was crying. She wasn’t wiping it away.

“I made it,” she said quietly. “Tessie. I made it.”

“You made it, Mom.”

“I walked you down the aisle. With hair.”

“With a lot of hair.”

She laughed. She put her hand on my cheek.

On my other side, Jacqueline was holding the rail with both hands. She was looking down. At the lawn. At the long gravel drive. At the gate, where she’d sat all day in her car with the door open.

“I’ve never been this high up,” she said. “In my whole life.”

Nobody said anything.

“It’s so small from up here,” she said. “All of it. Everything I was so worried about. It looks so small.”

She was quiet for a long time.

Then she turned and looked at me.

“Thank you,” she said. “For letting me up here.”

“It wasn’t me,” I said. “It was my mom.”

Jacqueline looked at my mother. At her thin arms and her short silver hair and her face lit gold by the setting sun.

“Maureen,” she said. “I don’t know how to thank you.”

My mother shrugged. “You paid for the crane.”

And for the first time since I’d known her, Jacqueline laughed. A real laugh. Not the loud one she used at parties. A small, surprised one. Like something had come loose inside her.


Uncle Pete got a picture of it from the ground.

It’s framed on our living room wall now. Four people in a yellow basket, high up in the sky, silhouetted against the sunset. You can’t really see our faces. You can’t tell who’s who. You can’t see anybody’s size or shape. Just four black outlines against a sky full of gold and pink.

Four people, lifted up together. Holding on to each other.


It’s been two years since the wedding.

Jacqueline goes to therapy now. Every Tuesday. She told Bruce about the scale. About Sunday mornings. About the notebook. He called me from his car afterward, sobbing. He’d had no idea. His whole life, he’d had no idea.

She goes to a support group, too. For women who’ve spent their whole lives fighting their bodies. She told me there’s a woman in her group who’s eighty-one. Eighty-one years old and still counting.

“I don’t want to be her,” Jacqueline told me. “I don’t want to be eighty-one and still counting.”

She’s not perfect. Once, last Thanksgiving, she started to say something when I took a second helping of stuffing. I saw her open her mouth. I saw her catch herself. She closed it again. She turned around and walked into the kitchen, and I heard her take a long, deep breath.

When she came back, she was carrying the pie.

She set it down in front of me.

“Here,” she said. “I made it. Your dad’s mom’s recipe. Maureen gave it to me.” She paused. “It’s a little burned on one side.”

I looked at the pie. At her. At her hands, shaking a little.

“Did you have some?” I asked.

She hesitated.

“No,” she said. “Not yet.”

I cut two slices. I put one on a plate. I held it out to her.

She looked at it for a long, long time.

Then she took it. She sat down next to me at the table. And she ate it. Slowly. One bite at a time. Not counting.

When she was done, she put her fork down very carefully on the empty plate.

“That was good,” she said. Her voice was shaking. “That was really good.”

“I know,” I said. “It’s the best thing I make.”


My mother is still in remission. Two and a half years clear. Her hair is down to her shoulders now. Silver and curly. She never dyed it. She says she earned every gray one.

She and Jacqueline have lunch once a month. I don’t know what they talk about. I’ve never asked. My mother says it’s “none of my business.” Bruce says he thinks they talk about us.

Last spring, I found out I was pregnant.

A girl. We found out at the twenty-week scan.

Bruce and I drove over to Jacqueline’s house to tell her. She sat on her perfect white couch and cried. Then she went to the kitchen and came back with a small box. Old. Wrapped in faded tissue paper.

Inside was a bathroom scale. An old one. Rusty. With a cracked glass face.

I stared at it.

“It’s the one,” Jacqueline said quietly. “From my mother’s house. The one she used to weigh me on. Every Sunday. Before church. I took it when she moved into assisted living. I don’t know why. I’ve kept it in my closet for thirty years.”

She held it out to Bruce.

“I want you to take it to the dump,” she said. “Before she’s born. Please. I want it gone. I don’t want it in this family anymore.”

Bruce took it. He didn’t say anything. He just held it.

“And I want you to know,” Jacqueline said, looking at me, “that I’ll never say a word about her body. Not one. Ever. I’ll never weigh her. I’ll never move her plate. I’ll never make a joke.” Her voice broke. “I’ll tell her she’s beautiful. Every single time I see her. Whether she’s big or small or anything in between. I’ll tell her she’s beautiful until she believes it.”

I looked at this woman. Who had rented a crane to humiliate me on my wedding day. Who was standing in her living room now, crying, holding out the scale that had broken her when she was ten years old.

“Okay,” I said.


Bruce took the scale to the county dump the next Saturday.

I went with him. So did Jacqueline. So did Nana June, who’s eighty-six now and uses a walker but insisted on coming.

We stood at the edge of the big metal dumpster. Bruce held the scale up. He looked at his mother.

“You want to do it?” he asked.

Jacqueline took it from him. She held it for a long moment. She looked down at the cracked glass face. At the little red needle.

Then she looked at Nana June.

“Mom,” she said. “Come here.”

Nana June shuffled forward with her walker. Jacqueline held out the scale. Nana June put her thin, spotted hands on it next to her daughter’s.

They held it together.

“On three,” Jacqueline said.

They didn’t count to three. They didn’t need to. They just let go.

The scale fell into the dumpster with a crash. The glass shattered.

Nana June started to cry. Jacqueline put her arm around her mother. The two of them stood there at the edge of the county dump, holding each other, crying, while seagulls screamed overhead and a garbage truck backed up somewhere nearby, beeping.

Bruce took my hand.

“Most romantic thing I’ve ever seen,” he said. “Two old ladies throwing a scale into a dumpster.”

“Second most,” I said.

“What’s the first?”

I looked at him.

“A man lifting his mother’s car into the sky,” I said. “With a crane she rented to make fun of me.”

He laughed. He put his hand on my belly.

“Well,” he said. “She did say I’d need help lifting.”


Our daughter was born in October.

Eight pounds, six ounces. A good, strong weight. The nurse said so when she put her on the scale. The first time anybody ever weighed her.

“Eight pounds six,” the nurse said. “She’s perfect.”

Jacqueline was in the waiting room when Bruce went out to tell everybody. He told me later that when he said eight pounds six, his mother put her hand over her mouth. He thought she was going to say something. Some old reflex.

She didn’t.

She just said, “Can I hold her?”

When she came into my hospital room, she walked very slowly. Like she was afraid of breaking something. Bruce put the baby in her arms.

Jacqueline looked down at her granddaughter. At the little round face. The chubby cheeks. The fat little fists.

“Oh,” she whispered. “Oh, look at you. You’re beautiful. You’re so beautiful.”

She said it again. And again. Standing there by the window with the baby in her arms and tears running down her face.

“You’re beautiful. You’re beautiful. You’re so beautiful.”

Like she was saying it to the baby.

Like she was saying it to herself, too. To a ten-year-old girl in a nightgown, on a Sunday morning, a long time ago.

Maybe she was.


We named our daughter Maureen June. After both her grandmothers’ mothers. After two women who survived things.

People ask me sometimes about the crane. About my wedding. It went a little viral, after Uncle Pete posted the picture. People find it strange. The crane. The car. The basket in the sky.

I tell them the truth.

My mother-in-law hired a crane because she thought I was too heavy to be lifted.

She was wrong about why.

But she was right about one thing.

I did need help lifting. We all do. My mother needed help lifting herself through a year of cancer. I needed help lifting the weight of that year off my shoulders. Jacqueline needed help lifting fifty years of Sunday mornings off hers.

Nobody gets lifted alone.

Not brides. Not mothers. Not little girls on bathroom scales.

You need somebody standing beside you in the basket, holding on to the rail, looking out at a sky so big it makes everything you were ashamed of look very, very small.

See more on the next page

3 of 4

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *