AT 19, MY BEST FRIEND AND I PROMISED THAT IF WE WERE BOTH SINGLE AT 60, WE’D FIND EACH OTHER. I TURNED 60 LAST TUESDAY, AND HE CALLED FROM A HOSPITAL BED.
ON THE CHAIR BESIDE HIM WERE 41 UNSENT LETTERS — AND THE TRUTH ABOUT WHY HE WALKED AWAY.
Chapter 1: The Landline That Rang
When we were 19, my best friend and I promised that if we were both single at 60, we’d find each other — I turned 60 last Tuesday, and my old landline rang.
My name is Ruth. Jeffrey and I were best friends from seventeen. At nineteen, under the football bleachers, he held out his pinky: “If we’re both single at sixty, we find each other.” Deal.
Then he left for college, and by the time I knew I loved him, he was marrying someone else, and his last letter asked me never to contact him again. I never married. I’d met the right man at seventeen.
Last Tuesday I turned sixty, and the landline rang. “I’m Peter, Jeffrey’s son. My father doesn’t have much time.” Then his voice: “Ruthie. I was in love with you when we made that promise. I’d already bought the ring. Come to the hospital. You’ll understand why I walked away.”
On the chair beside his bed was a wooden box: a velvet ring case, forty-one letters tied with string — one for every year, all addressed to me — and a framed drawing of me at nineteen, under the bleachers.
“I wrote you every birthday for forty-one years. I never sent them. Not after what I did to protect you. Sit down, Ruthie.”
Chapter 2: The Summer He Walked Away
I sat down beside the man I’d loved for forty-one years, and he told me the truth he’d been carrying since 1986, and it broke my heart and mended it in the same breath.
“The summer after our promise,” Jeffrey said, “before I left for school, I got sick. Really sick. The doctors ran tests, and they found something — a condition, a serious one, the kind they told me, at nineteen, would probably take me young. They gave me a handful of years. Maybe into my thirties, if I was lucky. That was the prognosis I got two weeks after I bought your ring.
I had the ring in my pocket, Ruthie. I was going to give it to you before I left. I’d planned the whole thing. And then I sat in a doctor’s office and got told I was dying, and everything changed.
Because I loved you too much to do it. I loved you too much to put a ring on your finger and make you a widow at twenty-five. I loved you too much to let you spend your best years watching me get sick and die, giving up everything you could have been to nurse a boy who wouldn’t see forty. I couldn’t do that to you. I couldn’t let you sign up for a marriage that was really just a countdown to a funeral.
So I made a decision. The worst and most loving decision of my life. I decided to let you go — to make you let me go — so you could have the whole, long, healthy life I couldn’t give you.
I met a woman at school. Her name was Carol. And Carol knew, from the start, what I was — I told her everything, the diagnosis, the prognosis, all of it. She married me anyway, with her eyes open, knowing she was probably signing up to be a young widow. She was a good woman, Ruthie. She wasn’t you — nobody was ever you — but she was kind, and she was brave, and she chose me knowing what it would cost.
I married her because I couldn’t marry you. Because marrying you would have destroyed your life, and marrying her only spent mine.”
Chapter 3: The Life He Didn’t Get to Live
“And then,” Jeffrey said, and here his weak voice cracked into something between laughter and grief, “I didn’t die.
The prognosis was wrong. Or the treatment worked, or I was the exception, or God has a sense of humor — I don’t know. But the years they gave me came and went, and I was still here. Thirty came. Forty. Fifty. I kept living, Ruthie. The death that made me let you go never arrived.
Do you know what that’s like? To give up the love of your life to spare her from your early death, and then to just… keep living? To realize, decade after decade, that you’d broken both your hearts for a funeral that didn’t come?
See more on the next page