The gray tomcat had guarded a frozen suitcase for eighteen hours when I heard four tiny cries coming from underneath his body.
Until that moment, I had believed what everyone else believed.
That he was mean.
That he was sick.
That he had taken over the back stairwell of my apartment building and needed to be removed before he hurt somebody.
I had seen the videos people recorded through the laundry room window. In every clip, the cat crouched over the same faded blue suitcase, his back raised and his yellow eyes fixed on whoever held the phone.
He was a big cat. Bigger than most house cats I had known.
His gray coat was thick but dirty. A pale scar crossed the bridge of his nose. One eye had turned cloudy with age, and the fur around his shoulders had thinned in uneven patches.
Both ears were whole and intact. They were just flattened whenever anyone stepped too close.
That was enough to make him look dangerous.
By the second day, people had started calling him the stairwell monster.
I was forty-three years old and had worked at that apartment building in Toledo for almost six years. My official job was property manager, but in a building that old, titles did not mean much.
I collected rent, changed furnace filters, cleared clogged drains, replaced smoke detector batteries, and answered the phone when somebody’s ceiling started dripping at midnight.
I also lived in a small one-bedroom apartment beside the maintenance room.
That meant every problem eventually became my problem.
The cat became my problem on a Tuesday morning in February.
The temperature had dropped hard overnight. The sidewalks were coated with old snow that had melted and frozen again. Pipes groaned inside the walls, and the wind found every crack around every window.
I was checking the laundry room because one of the washers had stopped draining when I first saw him.
He was under the metal stairs behind the building, pressed against a suitcase that looked like it had been thrown away years ago.
I opened the back door about six inches.
The cat lifted his head.
A low growl came from his chest.
I shut the door.
That should have been the end of it.
I had work orders stacked on my desk, three residents waiting for replacement heaters, and a boiler that had started making a sound like somebody dropping silverware down a pipe.
I did not have time to earn the trust of a stray cat.
Still, something about the suitcase bothered me.
It was lying on its side beneath him, wedged between the concrete wall and the bottom stair. The zipper was almost completely closed.
The cat was not sitting beside it.
He was covering it.
His front paws hung over one edge. His back legs curled around the other. He had spread himself across the fabric as if he were trying to keep something inside from getting cold.
I left a bowl of food near the door.
When I checked ten minutes later, he had not touched it.
By noon, a handwritten note had been taped to the laundry room wall.
DANGEROUS CAT OUT BACK.
PLEASE DO SOMETHING.
By three, there were two more notes.
By six, there was another video in the building’s online message group. It showed the cat swiping at a broom someone had pushed toward him.
The person filming laughed nervously and called him crazy.
I watched the video twice.
The cat never chased the broom.
He only knocked it away from the suitcase.
That evening, I warmed a can of cat food in the maintenance room and carried it outside.
I set it six feet from him, then backed away.
He watched me for a long time.
See more on the next page